Zhouyi BenyiLine statement
Yang, firm, central, and correct, dwelling in the honored position, it hears litigation and attains fairness. For the diviner who encounters it, if their dispute has merit, it will surely be vindicated.
6. Conflict (讼)
Line 5
5. The fifth line, undivided, shows its subject contending;—and with great good fortune.
Modern reading
Nine in the fifth place stands as the central, balanced arbiter whose impartiality resolves discord and brings supreme auspiciousness. Operating from integrity and fair principles enables leaders to settle controversies and command enduring respect.
Ask your AI about this page
Links prefill your prompt without sending it — you stay in control. If a link fails, copy the prompt below.
Prompt preview
I Ching / BaZi reading request (from eastalmanac.com). Page: Hexagram 6 讼 — Line 5. Interpret through classical principles in two layers: 1) Structural Evidence: identify key line dynamics, changing line pivot, or element balance. 2) Actionable Verdict: direct answer to the inquiry in plain language, followed by 2–3 concrete next steps (action-verb first) and mindful cautions. Grounded wisdom for self-reflection. Source page: https://eastalmanac.com/yijing/6/5
I Ching casting
Occupying the honored central position of the upper trigram, this line embodies a balanced judge capable of resolving conflict through even-handed fairness.
Traditional commentaries view its verdict as supremely auspicious because moral authority and strict neutrality dispel doubt among all parties. Standing firmly on transparent justice transforms lingering contention into lasting clarity.
Career
In workplace dilemmas and organizational conflicts, this position favors taking the high ground of objective judgment and standard procedures.
Classical perspectives indicate that treating every party equitably without favoritism resolves factional gridlock and cements authoritative leadership. Clear standards and fair-minded decisions earn the genuine confidence of your colleagues.
Love & relationships
Resolving sensitive relational divides requires open honesty, emotional transparency, and an equitable approach to mutual responsibilities. The classical reading advises that when grievances are addressed with fairness and mutual respect, emotional discord readily dissolves.
Speaking candidly without bias fosters reciprocal trust and deepens relational stability.
Wealth
Financial transactions and partnership arrangements benefit most from formal adherence to contractual terms and transparent accounting. Traditional frameworks view this line as an indicator of sound governance where clear documentation eliminates ambiguity.
Anchoring agreements in verifiable terms safeguards your interests and minimizes future disputes.
References
Original text
Small Image
‘He contends;—and ‘with great fortune:—this is shown by his holding the due mean and being in the correct place.
Classical commentary
Zhouyi BenyiSmall Image
Being central, the hearing is unbiased; being correct, the judgment accords with principle.
Yichuan YizhuanLine statement
Occupying the honored position with centrality and correctness, it governs conflict. Governing conflict while maintaining centrality and correctness brings supreme good fortune.
Supreme good fortune means great good fortune that is thoroughly good; there are cases where good fortune is great yet not entirely good.
Yichuan YizhuanSmall Image
Wherever the way of centrality and correctness is applied, how could it not bring supreme good fortune?
Zhouyi ZhuLine statement
Dwelling in the honored position as the lord of conflict, it uses centrality and correctness to judge the crooked and the straight. Centrality brings no excess; correctness leaves no crookedness.
Firmness is not deluded, and impartiality shows no bias; therefore conflict brings 'supreme good fortune.'
Zhouyi ZhengyiLine statement
'Nine in the Fifth Place: conflict, supreme good fortune.' The correct meaning: Dwelling in the honored position, central and correct, it judges lawsuits, hence obtaining 'supreme good fortune.'
Commentary: From 'Dwelling in the honored position' to 'therefore conflict brings supreme good fortune.'
The correct meaning: 'Dwelling in the honored position as the lord of conflict' means that occupying the position of Nine in the Fifth Place during a time of conflict, it is the lord who adjudicates lawsuits. However, within this hexagram, there are two lords who judge lawsuits.
Note that the earlier commentary stated, 'there must be a lord who is skilled at hearing litigation—is this not Nine in the Second Place?' That makes the second line the lord.
This commentary states, 'as the lord of conflict, it uses centrality and correctness to judge the crooked and the straight,' making the fifth also the lord. Having two lords in one hexagram is frequent among many hexagrams.
The fifth is the lord of the honored position in the hexagram, while other lines are lords of the hexagram's thematic meaning.
For instance, in Hexagram Fu (Return), Nine at the Beginning is the lord of Fu because the meaning of 'Return' resides in Nine at the Beginning; Six in the Fifth Place also occupies the honored position of Fu and is the lord of the honored position—such examples are not confined to a single hexagram.
The reason is that the fifth occupies the honored position, like the Son of Heaven directing all affairs and acting as lord to all things; hence in all hexagrams the fifth holds the honored position.
The other lines specialize in a single matter, like the Six Ministers where the Minister of Spring oversees rituals and the Minister of Autumn oversees punishments; each other line governs its own affair.
Thus the Six Ministers report to the Son of Heaven, and in all hexagrams the lines take Nine in the Fifth Place as the honored position.
If a hexagram is formed by the fifth position and the fifth also holds the honored position, there is just one lord, as with Nine in the Fifth Place in Bi (Holding Together).
Now in this Conflict hexagram, both the second and fifth are lords, both possessing the virtue of judging lawsuits; the fifth and second share this meaning, so both are considered lords.
Note: The Tuan commentary above says 'the firm comes and attains the middle,' and here the Xiang commentary of Nine in the Fifth Place says 'conflict brings supreme good fortune through centrality and correctness,' showing that 'the firm comes and attains the middle' in the Tuan commentary does not refer to Nine in the Fifth Place.
Wang Bi (Fusi) necessarily identified it as Nine in the Second Place because whenever between upper and lower images something is in the lower image, it is called 'coming.'
Hence Hexagram Bi (Grace) says 'the yielding comes and patterns the firm,' referring to Li below and Gen above where it is called 'the yielding comes.' Here it says 'the firm comes and attains the middle,' so we know it is Nine in the Second Place.
Furthermore, whenever 'coming' is used, it refers to arriving among a different category.
Nine in the Second Place sits between two yin lines, hence it is called 'coming'; Nine in the Fifth Place is in the outer trigram where all three lines are yang, so it cannot be called 'coming.'
As for the line statements, moving from the lower trigram to the upper trigram is also called 'coming'; hence Six at the Top in Waiting has 'three uninvited guests come,' referring to the three yang lines of the lower trigram coming.
Six at the Top in Waiting is a yin line, and the yang lines approach it, which is also an approach to a different category and thus called 'coming.' 'To judge the crooked and the straight'—crooked means bent.
Whenever two people litigate, one must be crooked and the other straight; Nine in the Fifth Place, in hearing litigation, is able to determine the crooked from the straight, hence 'to judge the crooked and the straight.'
Zhouyi ZhengyiSmall Image
The correct meaning: 'Because of centrality and correctness' explains the meaning of 'supreme good fortune.'
Why conflict attains great good fortune is because Nine in the Fifth Place occupies the center and attains the correct position; being central, it has no error; being correct, it has no bias. With centrality and correctness as its virtue, there is 'supreme good fortune.'
Yicuo JinLine statement
Nine in the Fifth Place, fifth line, supreme: Magpies chatter and flutter gracefully before the eaves; worries wash away, and joy arises naturally. As one advances and another withdraws, everything in the end will form a wonderful affinity.